Children aren't commodities
One recent Saturday as I was about to enter the park for a long walk with Fritz, a young German shepherd I adopted in April, I decided to check out an unusual sign for a multifamily fundraiser for families that wished to adopt children. The people I met were friendly, white and well-off financially. I learned that a few families were pooling together some items that had been gathering dust in an attempt to raise funds to adopt children from foreign countries. I left uncomfortable about the concept of selling castaway items for that purpose.
I wondered: Was there a shortage of children in the area who would benefit from the care and guardianship of a loving and financially secure family? I found out that there was no such shortage. I contemplated how funds that might be raised to secure an international adoption might help the children of our own region who have great need, but who may not be ideal candidates for adoption due to their age or other factors.
I then investigated and found that an international adoption typically could cost up to $50,000 in travel costs and fees -- legal fees, documentation fees, baby broker fees and probably other fees that are needed to grease the wheels of progress. Adoption, particularly international adoption, is big business, with youngsters as the commodity and a need to graft another person into a family tree the motivational force.
I found my skepticism growing toward the altruistic jargon used at the fundraiser. I concluded that the fundraising event wasn't about the child's welfare, but about possessing a child by any means. I asked myself: Why not just donate the money to the foreign orphanages to help the kids? But then the adoptive parents would not gain the child; these people who purchase a wanted commodity by selling off knicknacks are well-versed in the lingo of many websites dedicated to international adoption. Sadly, the commodities were human beings.
Decency mandates that children who have lost their family be given respect and empathy, not a yard sale. Do you suppose that one day the youngsters will ask to hear the heartwarming story of how their loving parents sold off some end tables to purchase them? I suspect they may be told how lucky they are that they have such spiritually generous parents.
Human beings, particularly defenseless and voiceless children, deserve better from society. This practice would be an outrage in a moral society, and is de facto human trafficking.
Seriously?! I love that he pointed out the he adopted his dog. Did he pay any fees to do that? I know we had to pay fees for our dogs when we adopted them. There was a rebuttal letter the next day from someone helping out with the yard sale. She did a good job telling this guy what an idiot he is. She also explained that at least one of the families in question would be doing an open adoption:
This particular couple is working with domestic agencies that specialize in open adoption because of the ability to keep a child connected with his roots and foster that relationship with the birth family. The notion of "buying a child" makes me livid. Parents don't tell their children about the hours they slave away in a cubicle on a 9-5 job to afford maternity hospital bills. Adoptions are expensive because time, effort and resources are not cheap. Most of the money is spent on counselors, prenatal care, food, housing for the birth mother and travel expenses.
I wonder if the writer of the original letter has children or has ever wanted children. I have lots of responses to what he said (i.e. why we don't feel we can do foster care or foster/adopt at this time, why a Russian adoption made us nervous because of the extra fees paid in-country), but I don't want this post to be any longer than it already is. In the future, I just hope I don't have to deal with this type of attitude face-to-face.

I think I'm gonna hurl. What a holier-than-thou ass-hat. I mean it's one thing to worry about human trafficking but it's entirely another to lump ALL international adoption into that category considering many international adoptions occur from orphanages. My favorite is the "aren't there children needing homes here?" comment. Why yes there is, hows about the writer adopting through foster care and see how that goes?
ReplyDeleteIdiots are out there, and you'll find them (or they find you?). Luckily, they are only a speck in the crowd of supporters you'll have. Especially on our little adoption blog roll!
ReplyDelete